Return to CreateDebate.comamericanlit • Join this debate community

OA-BCIG American Lit


Debate Info

17
38
Abolish Homework Homework is needed
Debate Score:55
Arguments:46
Total Votes:65
Ended:04/29/14
More Stats

Argument Ratio

side graph
 
 Abolish Homework (11)
 
 Homework is needed (33)

Debate Creator

drasmussen(15) pic



This debate has ended. You can no longer add arguments or vote in this debate.

Official Debate: Homework

Homework is a source of stress in many American households. This stress is compounded when both parents work or in single-parent households. Students are also busier than ever with after-school activities including sports, music lessons and part-time jobs, which leave little time for hours of homework. However, school reform movements like the No Child Left Behind Act that require schools to show improvement in student performance or lose funding make it more likely that homework is not going away. The National PTA and the National Education Association both endorse the "10-minute rule" created by Duke University psychology professor Harris Cooper. This rule says that students should get 10 minutes of homework a night per grade--a first grader would have 10 minutes of homework, a second grader 20 minutes, and so on. Critics of homework argue that too much of it is busywork that has little academic value.


Should homework be abolished?

Abolish Homework

Side Score: 17
VS.

Homework is needed

Side Score: 38
Winning Side!
3 points

It is no doubt that homework is a large debate in our society. Many people are starting to think that homework should be done away with because of the hustle and bustle of the young people in our society. Many students have a hard time finding the time to do homework with the things they are involved in whether it be sports, fine arts, or a part-time job. I think that with all these things going on, do students even retain the information long enough to say they know it? Most students retain the information just long enough to earn the grade in the class and do not know everything from year to year. I believe students should be taught what they need to know while they are at school, homework just adds more stress to students. If it requires an extra few days of school to make sure you get through all the material then so be it because it would be better than having homework all the time.

“Louis Menand: The End of Homework?" The New Yorker. N.p., n.d. Web. 22 Apr. 2014.

Side: Abolish Homework
2 points

Reasons why homework should be abolished: children, kids, and young adults, are busy with sports, playing outside, work, etc. but the point is that kids need to be kids, and the older ones need to be responsible. Also the high school kids that pay for their own vehicle, gas, basically all of their living don’t need the extra homework!! Another reason is situations in which there is single parents that have to work the late shift and left to baby is the older sibling that has homework to do. Kids need to play, just a simple fact of life and when you make them stay inside to do their homework do you really think your going to get quality work? Probably not I know when I was little I hurried through my homework to get to play. Homework makes kids hate school, I know its made me very angry with school. Overall, homework should be abolished because it not only is junk work, keeping kids inside on nice days, making the kids hate school, keeping the older ones up at night because they had to work, the kids that has to babysit his baby brother because his single mom is at work, but its keeping kids from being kids.

"Education Rethink @edrethink: Ten Reasons to Get Rid of Homework (and Five Alternatives)." Education Rethink @edrethink: Ten Reasons to Get Rid of Homework (and Five Alternatives). N.p., n.d. Web. 23 Apr. 2014.

Side: Abolish Homework
et2015(8) Disputed
1 point

Now of days kids don’t want to get their homework done because they want to play video games. Kids don’t want to go outside anymore and if they really wanted to they could take their homework outside with them.

I do see your point on when you have to work or when you have to babysit, but it teaches you how to manage things. Homework is given to you so you can practice what you are learning.

Side: Homework is needed
sbaker2015(8) Disputed
1 point

When i was little i remember getting to go play outside when i was done with my homework. I was never hurried through it. Homework is an important thing, it makes the students realize what the teacher is trying to teach to you. It allows the students to know what will be on the tests. Its like studying, but its an assignment. Yes, i know we all hate homework but i think that i'd rather have good grades and passing high school than flunking everything and never graduating.

Side: Homework is needed
tsharkey(8) Disputed
1 point

Students should have homework. The reason students don't want homework is because they just want to spend time with friends or play games. I understand that people have jobs, but if people did their homework in study halls or during success they wouldn't have much to do at home. I see most students during study hall or success messing around instead of doing homework. Most days students don't have homework and if they do, it isn't much. I think homework gives students the responsibility to do things on their own. It teaches them more about what they learned in class. If students don't have homework, most won't learn anything or when it comes to testing, they don't know what they're doing because they didn't study or have homework to practice. Most students don't even study for tests. In the article, "Studies Show Homework Isn't Much of a Burden" states, "In the 2012 college freshmen survey, students were asked how much they spent per week on various activities in their last year of high school. Nearly two-thirds said they spent six or more hours a week socializing with friends. But only 38.4 percent spent that same amount of time on studying or homework their last year in high school. Homework came in behind not only socializing but also exercise or sports as well as working for pay. That percentage is less than in 1986, when 49.5 percent of college freshmen said they spent six or more hours a week studying and doing homework in their last year of high school." This just shows that not a lot of students study. Doing homework is basically studying because you have to figure out what the answer is. Students should have homework everyday or every other day to help them practice what they are learning.

Supporting Evidence: Studies Show Homework Isn't Much of a Burden (sks.sirs.com)
Side: Homework is needed
1 point

People need the outdoors, I don't care what your family/siblings do mine are outside when it is nice out. Every night they have homework, it is a huge struggle to get it done because they don't want to come inside, they are having fun playing, the homework is annoying, and really they don't wanna come inside until it is dark. By the time its dark it is about bed time for a little guy, but wait I have homework to do. Is this homework making us smarter that we were earlier? Or is it just starting bad habits of rushing through everything. Most students do their homework at night, studies show that they are tired and cranky. Therefore they rush to get their homework done. A study showed from rush university in Chicago did a study that stated 22% of students fall asleep doing homework nightly. This doesn't even say the amount that are so tired they fill in answers, cheat, or simply don't do it.

Side: Abolish Homework
Cash(8) Disputed
1 point

You should really read this article http://lrs.ed.uiuc.edu/students/plato1/constructhome/page4.html It talks about how students need homework to develop good working habits, but I do agree with you that it should be cut down quite a bit so students have time to be kids.

Side: Homework is needed
2 points

Homework is one of the great causes that students dislikes school. Every year, the expectations with home works keep growing that motivates the students to rebel and fail to do the work. As homework keeps growing and growing each year, the amount of time spent doing it for us students kept getting larger and larger. Students has a lot of extracurricular activities spent after school such as sports, plays and work. By putting more and more school work load. Students began reducing effort in school work and even not do it at all. Due to this, educators result in making a punishment such as giving more harder homework. That will then again result to less motivation of students given to their school work. Students are expected to learn and work at a specific amount of time and at home students are expected to do their work until it's done. But the difference is at school, principals and teachers can control the situation and help the students that has troubles in class, this is not the case at home. Educators only see the product of what we do at home. Everyday, we are faced with situations that they cannot control. Many people think that homework creates good time management and good work habits when in fact its causes stress and leads students to dislike school.

Goldberg, Kenneth. "Why principals should be wary of homework: changing the homework structure for greater student success." District Administration Apr. 2014: 82. Student Edition. Web. 22 Apr. 2014.l.

Side: Abolish Homework
1 point

In France, the president Francois of France abolished homework for the primary and middle schools. Here is something you probably didn't know about France: its President has the power to abolish homework. In a recent speech at the Sorbonne, Francois Hollande announced his intention to do this for all primary- and middle-school students. He wants to reform French education in other ways, too: by shortening the school day and diverting more resources to schools in disadvantaged areas. France ranked twenty-fifth in a new evaluation of educational systems by the Economist Intelligence Unit (part of the company that publishes The Economist). To give you an idea how bad that is, the United States, whose citizens are accustomed to being told how poorly educated they are, ranked seventeenth. The French President's emancipation proclamation regarding homework may give heart not only to les enfants de la patrie but to the many opponents of homework in this country as well--the parents and the progressive educators who have long insisted that compelling children to draw parallelograms, conjugate irregular verbs, and outline chapters from their textbooks after school hours is (the reasons vary) mindless, unrelated to academic achievement, negatively related to academic achievement, and a major contributor to the great modern evil, stress. M. Hollande, however, is not a progressive educator. Source Citation (MLA 7th Edition)

Menand, Louis. "Today's Assignment." The New Yorker 17 Dec. 2012: 25. Student Edition. Web. 22 Apr. 2014.

the next site says Not many children will follow the proceedings of the teacher unions' conferences, but one motion might interest them: a call for homework to be abolished in primary schools. According to teachers belonging to the ATL in Cambridgeshire, Peterborough, Leeds and Wigan, formal homework set by teachers under the direction of the government is of dubious benefit.

Source Citation (MLA 7th Edition)

"Britiain's Schools: HOMEWORK: In primary schools, it's a waste of children's and teachers' time." Observer [London, England] 5 Apr. 2009: 9.Student Edition. Web. 23 Apr. 2014. Document URL

Side: Abolish Homework
haoareyou(1) Clarified
1 point

I want a clarification on which side you really are, because I saw that your in abolishing homework but your statement clearly shows that you are in the homework is needed side.

Side: Abolish Homework
everschoor15(14) Disputed
1 point

I am slightly confused on which side you are actually on, but since you are mentioning other countries, I figured I would mention Finland. Finland is known to have an outstanding education system which is actually completely different than schools in the United States. According to “26 Amazing Facts About Finland's Unorthodox Education System", children don’t start school until the age of 7 and finish once they are done with secondary school at the age of 15 or 16 . Once they do start school, they rarely have a lot homework and don’t take exams very often. In fact, students in Finland only take one required standardized test and that is when they are 16. In Finland, 93% of students graduate. That’s 17.5% higher than the US. Since Finland has such high rankings in education, naturally the US looks to them to see what we’re doing wrong. One of the obvious is homework and exams. I’m not for abolishing homework because that simply is unrealistic. Imagine going to math class and never practicing questions. How would you know how to do the problem? Maybe you might know how to do the problem if you’re a visual learner, but I certainly am not. As your research states that France is ranked 25th and that the US is ranked 17th, I don’t think abolishing homework is the answer.

Taylor, Adam. "26 Amazing Facts About Finland's Unorthodox Education System." Business Insider. Business Insider, Inc, 14 Dec. 2011. Web. 28 Apr. 2014.

Supporting Evidence: 26 Amazing Facts About Finland's Unorthodox Education System (www.businessinsider.com)
Side: Homework is needed
et2015(8) Disputed
1 point

We need homework to teach us how to handle stress. In the real world we will be faced with lots of stress. Much more than homework gives us and if we don’t have homework we will not know how to handle it. Homework also teaches you how to manage your time as said here by WebMD “With today's heavy homework loads, time-management and organizational skills are crucial weapons against stress, experts say.”

Supporting Evidence: WebMD (www.webmd.com)
Side: Homework is needed
haoareyou(1) Disputed
1 point

I agree that we need to learn how to handle stress but we also don't need that much stress put on to us in early age. And even if we don't have homework we will know how to handle it. We are faced with stress in our daily life, not just on homework. We also learn how to manage time by learning to do other things. I'm not saying don't study and learn the subject. I'm saying that by putting more and more homework, it stresses students that will lead them to not doing their homework, getting bad grades and giving up on school. Which is definitely what we don't need in the future.

Clark, Laura. "Homework Is a Waste of Time and Should Be Abolished, Say Teachers." Mail Online. Associated Newspapers, n.d.Web. 28 Apr. 2014.

Side: Abolish Homework
haoareyou(1) Disputed
1 point

I agree that we need to learn how to handle stress but we also don't need that much stress put on to us in early age. And even if we don't have homework we will know how to handle it. We are faced with stress in our daily life, not just on homework. We also learn how to manage time by learning to do other things. I'm not saying don't study and learn the subject. I'm saying that by putting more and more homework, it stresses students that will lead them to not doing their homework, getting bad grades and giving up on school. Which is definitely what we don't need in the future.

Clark, Laura. "Homework Is a Waste of Time and Should Be Abolished, Say Teachers." Mail Online. Associated Newspapers, n.d.Web. 28 Apr. 2014.

Side: Abolish Homework
2 points

I think young children need homework to learn how to spell words and add and subtract but once that got the basics down I think they should do their work in class so you don't have to take it home because a lot of students stay up really late just to get it done or they ask to cheat off someone else's because they didn't get it done. But I do remember Mr. Blum's class and he gave us homework but we always got it done in class which was nice so than if you had to go and do something after school or go to work but homework was holding you back. Even though you can't skip work but then you don't have your homework done it's just harder to get done when you get older I think.

Kaminski, Margaret A. "Help desk." Choices/Current Health Mar. 2014: 24. General OneFile. Web. 24 Apr. 2014.

Document URL

http://go.galegroup.com/ps/i.do?id=GALE|A360357645&v;=2.1&u;=0504bcighs⁢=r&p;=ITOF&sw;=w&asid;=dd5f205e11d0d2e0071360b6fa7511b4

Side: Abolish Homework
1 point

In the article Does Homework Work? states in the first grade you should study 10-20 minutes and add 10 minutes to every grade as you go up. This means juniors would have 110 minutes of studying. I think this is stupid because some of us have jobs and don't get off till 9 or 10 o'clock. Adding almost 2 hours at the end of the night doing home work means less sleep for students and they come to school all tired and don't pay attention in class causing them to not understand what the teachers are teaching. I would say no home work for kids.

"Does Homework Work?." Asbury Park Press. 10 Sep. 2013: n.p. SIRS Issues Researcher. Web. 28 Apr. 2014.

Side: Abolish Homework
1 point

In the article Does Homework work? states that that when the kids get frustrated they lose the interest of doing home work and don't want to do it because, they feel like there never going to get it right and under stand it. Like when your mom or dad don’t get algebra or science they can’t help you with it and u just give up on it, and you just get more frustrated with it.

"Does Homework Work?." Asbury Park Press. 10 Sep. 2013: n.p. SIRS Issues Researcher. Web. 28 Apr. 2014.

Side: Abolish Homework
1 point

Homework causes a lot of stress and does no good to me, I think it is a waste of time. Studies show that to much homework can actually lower test scores, cause stress and depression, and interfere with the students life. Homework is time consuming and a very upsetting when you have nobody to help you. Work, school, sports, and family activities are all more important than homework and seem to take up all of a teenagers life leaving no room for homework. If a student is worried about getting higher test scores than they will study or ask for help we don't need homework.

http://factualfacts.com/science-facts/too-much-homework-can-cause-stress-depression-and-lower-grades-studies-suggest/

Side: Abolish Homework
1 point

I am honestly on the fence with this but eventually one side won me over. Why? I found that homework is actually a tool to build responsbility, which is why I was on the fence, and that is also my opinion. Looking toward the future of big, high-paying jobs maybe in advertising, agricultural, or technological industries there will possibly be a lot of paperwork and projects due on specific dates. Looking at this from a distance, it seems homework depends on the student 20-30 years later. I got to thinking this way because of this article:

Peake, Maggie. "Extroverts vs. introverts." Skipping Stones Apr.-June 2014: 8. General OneFile. Web. 22 Apr. 2014.

Supporting Evidence: Extroverts vs. Introverts (go.galegroup.com)
Side: Homework is needed
1 point

Honestly, homework is a pain to do, but it is needed to learn. Homework is a vital tool that is looked at like it's a waste of someone’s time. I might be sounding like a hypocrite but I know this is true. On this college website that I found named education.cu-portland.edu,it states that homework helps you with four traits. The four traits are responsibility, time-management, perseverance, and self-esteem. I agree with the first two, but the last two are little out there but i'm not in college so yeah. If you do your homework, you also will re-learn what you learned in class during school. Also, you can use the homework to study for test in a subject instead of looking off your notes. You can look at problems that might be on the upcoming test that you need to study forhjfgfgv. With the time management skill, while doing homework, you can plan out your day better so that it will go well as planned. A organised schedule is better than a mess and this skill will help you a lot in the future. My final verdict is that homework is needed and should not be taken away from the students of schools. I, JudgeZach, rest my case of Homework.

Supporting Evidence: Education.cu-Portland.edu (education.cu-portland.edu)
Side: Homework is needed
1 point

I believe that homework is needed. There are a lot of students out there that have work or extracircular activities and after those activities they are probably going to be tired, but they have to take the responsibility to do their homework. Homework gives students the responsibility to finish it. Homework helps students figure out the work on their own. In class, there is probably only one person answering questions or the teacher is doing most of the work, but at home the student would have to do the work on their own. If they need help with it, they could ask a parent or friends or the teacher, but they shouldn't rely on other people to do their work. The article I read had a good point. The article, "Does Homework Work?" stated that, "Homework should serve to consolidate skills and develop creativity in students by having them apply the concepts of what was previously learned during the day." Homework is much needed for students that need help or students that like extra practice. I like doing extra practice because if I didn't get it before, I could practice and try to understand it. There is some days that I don't like having homework because I might be busy that day, but it's a part of life to have to do homework, go to work, and go to school. I think that homework is needed in schools to help students better understand the lesson that is being taught in school.

Supporting Evidence: Does Homework Work? (sks.sirs.com)
Side: Homework is needed
1 point

I can honestly say i don’t like having homework. But lets be real here, if our teachers didn’t assign us homework some of us students wouldn’t know what the teachers have been teaching for the last couple of weeks. Homework may be a hassle in our minds but in the long run it really does help us. It helps refresh our minds on what's been going on in class so we don’t just forget about it. In this site it tells us the importance of homework-https://sites.google.com/site/importanceofhomework/pros- None of us like homework, but would you rather know what’s going on in class and have good grades when it comes to assignments and tests or would you rather fail everything? The time spent after school on class assignments may help students better remember their material and further more enforce what they learned in school that day. Homework can also keep the parents informed about what their son or daughter is learning at school.

Side: Homework is needed
1 point

I think that homework is good for students because it helps them to focus on what is going on in their classes. http://today.duke.edu/ did some reaserch by comparing students who are assigned homework with students assigned no homework but who are similar in other ways. The results of such studies suggest that homework can improve students' scores on the class tests that come at the end of a topic. Students assigned homework in 2nd grade did better on math, 3rd and 4th graders did better on English skills and vocabulary, 5th graders on social studies, 9th through 12th graders on American history, and 12th graders on Shakespeare. This experiment helps to prove that homework does help.

Side: Homework is needed
1 point

“Homework is very necessary. It is a good tool used in school that improves students' understanding of what they learned in class. Homework is practice and practice makes perfect. Homework allows students to do work on their own without in class guidance and figure things out. This helps them learn better.” says Debate. We need homework so we can learn to do things on our own. It usually doesn’t take that long to do and for the most part it is easy. If you don’t know how to do it then you can look it up on the internet or you can simply ask your teacher in the morning.

Supporting Evidence: Debate (www.debate.org)
Side: Homework is needed
1 point

Homework will always be needed to help students succeed in their classes. Even though it is annoying and a lot of the time we don't want to do it, it helps up learn more, and become better students. For example if you were planning on going into accounting you would have to master everything that has to do with accounting. You wouldn’t want to get a job in an accounting firm and have no idea what you were doing. With homework you can take what you learned from class and apply it to the real world. At least that is what the teachers tell you. Personally I think that homework is the key to making more money in the real world. With more education you can get a higher paying job, and possibly be in a more important position in whatever company you work for.

Side: Homework is needed

I believe that homework is definitely needed. Without it we probably wouldn’t know what the teacher has taught or probably wouldn’t learn as much. Most of us don’t like it, but that’s because we think we have too much. Because we have too much homework, we complain about it more often or sometimes don’t even attempt to do it. There’s been plenty of times where I’ve gotten pointless assignments that don’t benefit my learning at all.

Up in the description, it mentions the “10 minute rule”. If we went by that rule, that means as an 11th grader, I’d have 110 hours of homework to do after school. Almost two hours! That’s certainly way too much. I shouldn’t have to take home almost two hours of homework. If I worked that night until ten, that means I would be up till after midnight. Then that means I wouldn’t be getting enough sleep.

I’m not for abolishing homework altogether because it’s definitely needed to learn. Principal, Alfie Kohn states in “Rethinking Homework”, that “The negative effects of homework are well known. They include children’s frustration and exhaustion, lack of time for other activities, and possible loss of interest in learning.” I can definitely agree with this. The nights where I have a ton of homework, I feel exhausted and definitely frustrated. Plus, I don’t have time for other activities if I have too much homework.

So what’s the answer to this problem? Alfie Kohn states, “Find out what students think of homework and solicit their suggestions – perhaps by distributing anonymous questionnaires. Many adults simply assume that homework is useful for promoting learning without even inquiring into the experience of the learners themselves!”

After research, I believe that homework is necessary. We can’t just abolish it just because we hate it so much. The solution to this is simply to give us less homework that would be beneficial to our time.

"Rethinking Homework." Rethinking Homework. N.p., n.d. Web. 23 Apr. 2014.

Supporting Evidence: Rethinking Homework (www.alfiekohn.org)
Side: Homework is needed
1 point

It's not very hard to find out that kids really don't like getting homework. With sports and other extra curricular activities it just really drains the students. Homework just adds to the stress and doesn't help the exhaustion level within that student. But is getting rid of the homework really the answer. Homework may be a pain, but it helps with that extra practice to understand the concept that was previously taught in class. It gives the student that time to try and figure out something they may not have understood before. Also, homework is a way the parents could possibly help their child understand what is being taught in a way they will understand. Homework isn't meant to be stressful, even though 90 percent of the time it is. It is meant to help and help further that students education to get them ready for college. I don't think homework should be abolished because yes, I hate doing it as much as the next kid, but in the end it really does help. "New Term, New Battle over Homework." BBC News. N.p., n.d. Web. 25 Apr. 2014.

Supporting Evidence: Homework (www.bbc.com)
Side: Homework is needed
schlender(9) Clarified
1 point

Rachelle has made some good points that even if we don't exactly like doing homework in the end it is supposed to help the student learn/understand what they learned in class that day. Having homework in school teaches responsibility characteristics in students. By getting homework it prepares students for the future for either going to college, where you will receive quit a bit of homework, or to go into the work force. While having a job you much be responsible for what you are there for, like students and school you're here to learn and better yourself. Another argument that you could make is not having time for sports. It is the students choice to go out for sports, if they can't having homework and participation they need to take it into their own hands and either try harder in school and use their time more wise or not do sports.

Supporting Evidence: Homework (www.sedl.org)
Side: Abolish Homework
1 point

I feel that students don’t want to do homework, because of the effort they have to put into it, but im just as guilty sometimes. If kids don’t want to do homework, it will be a rough road for them ahead in life, thats why parents and teachers should do the most they can do to make sure the children are understanding what they are learning. Its the lack of attention that plays a key problem in this topic. I feel that students want to learn but they don’t like the routine of homework.

Side: Homework is needed
1 point

I agree with you that students want to learn but do not like the routine of homework, but it also has to be something they want to learn. According to http://www.edutopia.org/homework-no-proven-benefits " no study has ever demonstrated any educational benefit to assigning homework before children are in high school. Even in high school the association between homework and success is weak." Kids may want to learn but they have to having the willingness to put in the effort that it takes to learn, which would include all of the homework they don't want to do. A lot of students do not do homework because they don't see the point in it or just don't want to put in the effort that it takes to achieve success. With anything anyone does in life even in there jobs, there are going to be things they don't want to do, even if they think they have the best job in the world there will still be parts that they hate about it, whether it be paper work or physical activity. You can't always do just what you want or think is fun because that is not the way the world works.

Side: Homework is needed
1 point

I believe that we should still have homework but a lot less than what we get. I feel like homework is a good tool to help people become more responsible and helps them learn what is need, but it also tend to stress the students out who do things after school, such as work or athletics. I feel like i am in the middle between both of these, but homework is needed.

Supporting Evidence: homework (www.debate.org)
Side: Homework is needed
1 point

Sunny I agree with you. Homework does build responsibility. I also believe that homework helps show the teachers that you know and understand what you have learned for the day. Homework is good but to an extant. When students grow up and get really good jobs, there might be a time where you are needed to make a powerpoint thats due in a week. Kids who get their work done on time will be able to do this but, other kids might not think so. Homework help strengthen the brain and help feel your vocabulary. Students learn how to manage their time wisely in order to get all the work done. For example, after school they may have track or softball and when they get home the only thing that the student wants to do is go to bed. But, knowing that they have work to do, they manage to finish it for the next day. Hartley, James. "Is homework good for you?" Psychology Review Sept. 1999: 26. General OneFile. Web. 25 Apr. 2014. Although this is all based on opinion, I read that “a clear relationship between the time that the pupils reported that they spent on homework and achievement in school examinations, with the best achievement being recorded by pupils who spent over 75 minutes each weekday evening on their homework.” It doesn’t take very long to do a little homework before bed or going out.

Side: Homework is needed
1 point

I like a lot of people believe that homework is needed but, I do not think it should be given in an overwhelming quantity. According to http://www.scholastic.com/teachers/article/homework-why-it-important, homework reinforces skills concepts and information learned in class which I think is true, but still if it is given in an overwhelming amount and is just busy work for a student who, keep in mind, will still get homework in other classes and possibly more important classes, but they still feel an obligation to get all of their homework done and then will be overwhelmed and go through the possibilities of not doing any of it or only doing what the student feels is important, than in which case you are setting the student up for failure.

There is also the fact that homework teaches a student to be independent and develops self-discipline. Which I believe to be true and it does teach responsibilty, but if the student finds the homework to be overwhelming or not worth doing they simply won't do it

Side: Homework is needed
1 point

Homework is not always a bad thing but some kids stress on homework if they don't get it. In "Starting from behind : community college create pathways to assist students who aren't prepared for the work." It says that the National and Science Initiative 45 percent of the u.s. high school graduates in 2011 were prepared to handle college math courses. 30 percent were prepared for college science. I think this helps them learn that doing homework really helps kids learn that in college you get tougher homework. That you will get more to teach people what they need they need to learn in life and why we need to give people homework .

Side: Homework is needed
1 point

Homework is very much needed in school. Sometimes teachers give us too much, and sometimes teachers don't give us any. According to Jillian Bichsel, director of academic services in Quaker Valley, she says that homework is a good time to practice the skills they have learned in the classroom. Both the National PTA and the National Education Association favor the rule-of-thumb limiting homework in all subjects to 10 minutes times the grade level. A first grader, for instance, would only have no more than 10 minutes of homework a night. I understand as you get older the homework gets tougher and longer, but in the end it is all worth the trouble. Also, homework scores bring your grades up if you just do them. It is all worth it, just take the time to do it right. This is why I am in favor of homework 100%.

Side: Homework is needed
1 point

There are different kinds of homework. There is purposeful homework and just busy work. Purposeful homework is designed for students to complete the work and it can involve parents in the right ways. With the parents knowing, this helps so the parents understand how much homework they have. There needs to be a correct amount of homework each night. Homework can help students learn how to manage their time, make good choices, and organize everything.

Side: Homework is needed
1 point

Homework can frustrate many people. When you are at home and you can't understand how to do your assignment, it can be very frustrating. Students can get so frustrated where they show violence. According to Dr. Donna W. Jorgensen, this is a problem with teenage students.

Side: Homework is needed
1 point

According to Dr. W. Donna Jorgenson, in her 45 years of education, she has given a fair share of homework. She has worked both pre-service and in-service to talk about the concerns over the homework wars. The parents will understand what is being asked for the homework. Lessons will go more smoothly, and result in a better way.

Side: Homework is needed
0 points

Homework is definitely an important part of school work. As annoying and stressful as it is on students, even those with a job, it is necessary because it helps with responsibility, learning, and it even helps the teachers. I found on http://www.cesdp.nmhu.edu/ that it helps with responsibility by teaching time management, and to have your work done on time. Homework doesn't end in school, its a part of life, making sure that we can have our work done on time. It also helps with learning for the student, helping them to memorize what they have been taught. This is the most important part because they can have practice to actually memorize what they need to know. And finally, it can help the teachers greatly. It can show, quite well what students need help. Many students that need help don't want to ask the teacher because they feel embarrassed. So, provided the teacher is taking that into account, homework is the gift from the schools, even if it's annoying and we don't see it now.

Side: Homework is needed
1 point

I agree especially with the responsibility part. Most students will go on and have a career of their own. Homework teaches students responsibility and will help them in their future with their future jobs. I read in an article called Ages and Stages on healthychildren.org that when students get to fourth grade, they have develop the proper skills that they are capable of doing homework and capable of developing responsibility skills.

Side: Homework is needed
0 points

I am for having homework, but in reduced amounts. According to the article Does Homework Work on SIRS, it says that having homework at an early age helps young students develop better learning abilities and techniques. The article does however go on to mention that the amounts of homework some students receive is way too overboard. Studies have shown that too much homework can lead to depression, stress, and lack of physical activity. Students need to have homework so they can practice what they are learning. If they don’t practice what they learn, odds are they will forget what they learned. But kids still need to enjoy their youth, therefore, students should still have homework, but it smaller amounts.

Does Homework Work?." Asbury Park Press. 10 Sep. 2013: n.p. SIRS Issues Researcher. Web. 23 Apr. 2014.

Side: Homework is needed
1 point

I agree with Cash homework is needed without it the teachers wouldn't know if you understand it or not. Yes is a pain to do but I will admit its something that we need but in less amounts. Studies show that we need homework too. Homework allows students and teachers to work more closely together. They can discuss their assignments or any problems that they are having with parts of their homework or reading, before or after classes so there ready for the test or quiz. Homework is kind of like a sport you have to practice in order to do good when you compete.

"5 Reasons Kids Need Homework and 5 Reasons They Don't." 5 Reasons Kids Need Homework and 5 Reasons They Don't. N.p., n.d. Web. 24 Apr. 2014.

Side: Homework is needed
1 point

I agree, homework is necessary, but to a certain extent. Too much homework can actually lower test scores. m.lifescience.com says that in countries whose schools give a lot of homework, the standardized test scores are lower than countries that don’t give much homework. One to two hours of homework per week does not seem to affect scores either way. “Busy work” does not have very much educational value at all. Homework is ok, but in moderation.

"Too Much Homework Is Bad for Kids." LiveScience.com. N.p., n.d. Web. 25 Apr. 2014.

Side: Homework is needed
0 points

I can actually see both sides of this argument but I decided to defend the idea of keeping homework because I think it can still be constructive. www.ascd.org stated that if a district or school discards homework altogether it will be throwing away a powerful instructional tool. In the article I read it talked about how homework can still be an effective form of learning if teachers are assigning it appropriately and using it to see what students might need more help without the student having to ask for it. There are lots of negatives to homework such as stress, exhaustion, and possible loss of interest in learning but only when given in excessive amount with little value. "Perhaps the most important advantage of homework is that it can enhance achievement by extending learning beyond the school day. This characteristic is important because U.S. students spend much less time studying academic content than students in other countries do. A 1994 report examined the amount of time U.S. students spend studying core academic subjects compared with students in other countries that typically outperform the United States academically, such as Japan, Germany, and France." I'd agree that homework can add extra stress to students' lives but later when they have jobs they will also have to deal with the stress of the tasks assigned with the job. Homework has been a endless debate for decades.

Supporting Evidence: ASCD (www.ascd.org)
Side: Homework is needed
0 points

Homework is needed because it helps kids learn the subject they are being taught. It allows kids to work at their own pace and get things done. In examiner.com it said that it teaches the students to develop good work habits. Homework also allows kids to prepare for tests or quizes. If teachers didn’t give homework students wouldn’t do a darn thing and their grade would reflect that. I personally like homework because if I have a bad grade in class I want assignments so I can get the grade up. Homework is a good thing.

Supporting Evidence: Homework Good (www.examiner.com)
Side: Homework is needed
1 point

I agree with Hunter. Homework can be very helpful to students who need more time with the subject they are working on. You cant expect someone to sit in a math class all day and know how to do every problem correctly without trying them on their own. Many think their is no point to homework because it doesn't yield long term results, like scholastic.com that says homework isnt helping students but just frustrates them. While this may be true, I feel it's needed because without it students could sit through class and never learn anything. Then when it's time to take a test they fail.

Supporting Evidence: Homework (www.scholastic.com)
Side: Homework is needed